Summary
Avengers: Doomsdaywill release on July 18, 2025,and is set to be a major blockbuster event for Marvel Studios. Bringing many characters together from within the franchise will instantly capture a lot of attention, which means that all of the decisions made throughoutAvengers: Doomsdayhave to be taken seriously, as they can have a significantly negative impact in the long run.
Marvel could end up taking that risk with Antony Mackie’s Captain America, especially if the writers decide to follow an idea that he wants to implement for his character if a potential showdown with Chris Evans takes place throughout the film.
Anthony Mackie Wants A Verbal Showdown In Avengers: Doomsday
The cast ofAvengers: Doomsdayisn’t confirmed at this stage, butthere have been manyrumors pointing towards Evans making another returnto the Marvel Cinematic Universe for this film. While he’s not expected to be playing Captain America again, it has led to a lot of speculation about the possibility of him having a confrontation with Mackie’s Captain America. That character is only starting to be developed afterCaptain America: Brave New Worldand a potential showdown between the two actors who have taken on the iconic role could lead to an amazing scene that would benefit Mackie’s version.
The idea isn’t just something MCU fans have spoken about, butMackie has also addressed it. During an interview withScreenRant, he said, “There’s a certain understanding between the two characters that it’ll be like De Niro and Pacino inHeat.That’s what I would be most excited about, is the idea of being able to act it out instead of duke it out.”
Anthony Mackie’s Plan Will Make His Captain America Look Weak
A potential verbal showdown between Sam Wilson and an evil character played by Evans would certainly be an interesting option for Marvel Studios to consider. Fans would undoubtedly want to see that, as the two actors are talented enough to drive the tension and make a scene gripping from start to finish. However, just seeing them talk about their problems would likely have a negative impact on Mackie’s version of Captain America, which issomething Marvel Studios must avoid.
From the moment that he took on the shield from Evans, there have been a lot of question marks about whether or not the right decision was made. There’s no doubt that Wilson’s character has the qualities to be Captain America, but his first lead movie in that position has divided people. Witha 50% critics rating onRotten Tomatoes, Captain America: Brave New Worldhasn’t been the hit that it needed to be in a bid to establish him in this role. That is why following Mackie’s idea for hischaracter inAvengers: Doomsdaywould be a major mistake as it wouldn’t help make him feel more important; in fact, it would do the opposite.
Marvel Studios Must Be Careful With Anthony Mackie’s Captain America In Avengers: Doomsday
Avengers: Doomsdayis going to be a crucial movie for Mackie’s future within the MCU, as this is a big opportunity to make the character feel just as important as it always has been. One way of achieving that would be to have himlead The Avengers just as Evans' version did. It would help to push him to the top of the MCU again and showcase that he means just as much as ever. But that also means he must be taken seriously whenever things break down and fights are required. Wilson might not boast the strength that Rogers did, but he should still be able to hold his own against other characters in the MCU.
Having the two characters involved in a fight sceneis what audiences are desperate to see, as it would create a compelling moment withinAvengers: Doomsday. They would likely be evenly matched due to the fact they’re both skilled in hand-to-hand combat, and that could make a fight scene brilliant to watch. Seeing them fight would not only be more exciting than a conversation, but it would have the opportunity to establish the new version of Captain America properly. Rogers might’ve handed over the shield, but he’s still viewed as the true version of the character in many people’s eyes. Having Wilson defeat whatever evil variant Evans plays would make a big difference in changing that.
If Wilson could overcome Evans' character, it would showcase his strengths and ensure that people take him seriously. It wouldcreate a memorable moment withinAvengers: Doomsdaythat audiences would keep talking about long after the fact, and it would also benefit Wilson moving forward. This will be crucial if Marvel Studios wants Mackie to be the face of the MCU in the foreseeable future, and this is why his idea should be completely ignored.
