Summary
Consideringsurvival horror gamescan already be utterly terrifying due to their intense gameplay and environments, most games will allow the protagonist to say a few words of encouragement here and there to ensure players that they aren’t alone. If developers really want to crank up the scare factor though, they can decide to feature a silent protagonist, making them more of a fil-in for the player, who can feel as though they are really there living the nightmare for real.
It can’t be an easy decision creating a mute protagonist, since it can make building up a story a bit more difficult, but thankfully, developers have found plenty of fun and unique ways to keep the narrative going, without the protagonist needing to say a word. With that being said, these are the very best games in the genre where the protagonist, outside of a few grunts and deep breaths, remains completely silent for the entire story.
While there is a light story that runs throughoutThe Forest, at the core of the game is the immersive survival simulator which tasks players with surviving on an island full of cannibals after a sudden plane crash. As a result, the game is largely devoid of any real conversations, since many of the tribes will tend to attack the player rather than trying to reason with them.
This really works in the game’s favor though, as, thanks to the realistic graphics,FPS view, and excellent audio design, it’s hard to find many survival horror games out there that pull off immersion quite as well asThe Forest. Though it might not be as polished as most triple AAA survival horrors, and features a largely straightforward plot,The Forest’sgameplay is still fantastic, and having a silent protagonist only feeds into that.
ThoughFive Nights At Freddy’smight play quite a bit differently than most survival horror games, it’s primarily because it puts more emphasis on management, that is, being able to keep track of multiple things at once to avoid being taken out. In this case, the protagonist is Mike Schmidt, who must try to use the side doors of his office to prevent a group ofdeadly animatronicsfrom reaching him. Of course, this is much easier said than done, as there will only be a limited amount of power each night for players to use, so patience really is a virtue here.
While Mike is a character who is actually fairly important to the wider lore, having him speak would simply break the nail-biting intensity of the gameplay. Therefore, keeping him quiet amplifies the scares and allows the setting to feel unnervingly real, making for one of the most popular survival horror games of the modern era.
WhileAmnesia: Rebirthwas a pretty well-received game that many fans came to enjoy, one problem which would constantly break the immersion is how often the protagonist, Tasi, would talk. This is presumably a part of the reason whyAmnesia: The Bunkerwould have a silent protagonist, but this decision was also made because of the gameplay’s emphasis on sound. As the name implies, the game takes place in a bunker; one which is being stalked by a vicious monster whose sense of hearing is second to none.
Therefore, the core gameplay loop revolves around opening doors,solving puzzles, and just simply trying to survive, all while creating as little noise as possible. This begins to get extremely difficult once players are forced to use bullets, bombs, and engines to help them progress through each area, and while the game is fairly short, and there’s the occasional stutter here and there, it’s still well worth playing for anyone who wants a truly immersive stalker game.
The remake of the 1994 classic changes up quite a bit from the original, but one thing that has remained intact is the silent protagonist, who is simply known as the Hacker. As players make their way through the mutant-infested space station, they will be able to learn more about how it became overridden by these vile creatures, while also being regularly contacted by the spine-chilling maniacal AI known as SHODAN.
Not having the protagonist say anything actually feeds intoSystem Shock’sstory, since it’s implied that this nameless hero could be anyone, and is emblematic of some of the game’s central themes. At the same time, it also just adds a ton of realism to the game by pulling players into the adventure thanks to its immersion.
While the remake of the originalDead Spaceprovided the game with a drastic graphical overhaul, alongside plenty of new mechanics and greatly improved audio, it also gave Isaac a voice. It might be hard to believe considering how much he chats back and forth with Kendra and Hammond inthe remake, but back in 2008, Isaac was little more than a stand-in for the player, despite still being his own character with his own personal motivations.
This would actually end up being a fairly divisive option when the game was first released. While the gameplay loop of exploring the dark and dreary Ishimura and blasting apart Necromorphs was an absolute blast, Isaac’s silence did end up making him feel a bit disconnected from the story. However, others argue that it helps to make the experience more immersive for the player, so it ultimately ends up being a double-edged sword, but despite the debates, it still serves its purpose extremely well in making the Ishimura feel all the more believable in all the worst ways.
After trying to get the latest scoop on the infamousMount Massive Asylum, Miles Upshur eventually finds himself trapped in the building with little more than a camera to guide his way. Considering the majority of the inmates are bloodthirsty and more than happy to kill anyone who looks at them the wrong way, staying silent for the entire adventure seems pretty understandable, and also adds to the immersion ofOutlast, especially when paired with the FPS camera angle.
Though there are a few characters who will talk directly to Miles, this is essentially just to give him new orders on where to go, though whether they can be trusted is an entirely different matter. The core gameplay ofOutlastis still just as intense as it was back in 2013, with the reliance on the camera and lack of weapons resulting in a memorable horror experience packed full of enemies who are pure nightmare fuel.
Aside from a quick comment before the game officially begins about his parents, Jack never speaks throughout his bizarre journey into the murky depths of Rapture in the originalBioShock. However, while at first, this can seem like it’s purely for immersion’s sake, Jack’s silence, and more specifically, his willingness to do anything asked of him, actually feeds into the game’s story.
BioShockplays around with itsmeta commentaryquite frequently, and one way it does this is through highlighting the absurdity of having a silent protagonist, and what not asking questions can ultimately lead to. Of course,BioShock’sgameplay is also incredible, with the enemy variety, Plasmid mechanic, and choice system all holding up to this day.
